Call (301) 832-4591 Ask a question

Compare remodeling estimates Compare the work before the totals.

Two remodeling estimates can describe different jobs. Put the work, the selected products and the unanswered questions beside each other before deciding what the difference in price means.

For Stamp's project scope, see remodeling.

Start with the same version of the project.

Check the date and revision of each estimate. Then write one sentence describing the project you want compared: which room, what should change and what should stay. If one proposal follows an earlier layout, mark that difference before comparing its total with a newer plan.

Read the descriptions beside the amounts. If one estimate covers a different layout, fewer rooms or different products, ask what you would need to change to compare the same project. Keep useful differences visible rather than treating every proposal as an interchangeable price for the same result.

Read the boundaries of the work.

Use the same questions for each proposal. Record what the document says, then mark an unanswered item for discussion. A blank space in your comparison does not mean the work is included or excluded.

Questions for comparing the scope of a kitchen or basement remodel
Part of the projectWhat to compare
Rooms and layoutWhich rooms and layout changes are described? Are adjoining areas part of the work?
Items to keepWhich cabinets, appliances, fixtures or finishes remain, and what work around them is included?
Products and finishesWhich choices are identified? Which are undecided or described only by a general category?
Electrical and other tradesWhich work is included, and who coordinates it with the rest of the remodel?
Removal and finishingWhat comes out, and what restoration, painting, cleanup or disposal is described?
Exclusions and optionsWhat is outside the base proposal? Which alternatives need a separate decision?

For example, installing a new light and repairing the ceiling around it are separate scope questions. Ask whether both appear in the proposed work. This is a question about the estimate, not a direction to alter the wiring or ceiling yourself.

Separate a selected product from an open choice.

A named appliance model is different from a request for a new range. A selected cabinet line is different from an undecided cabinet style. Keep the product information you already have with the proposal it belongs to, and ask which selections are still needed.

If an estimate uses an allowance, ask what that amount covers and how a later selection changes the proposal. If it offers an alternate, ask whether that is part of the base scope or an optional change. Do not assume two contractors use those terms in exactly the same way.

You can compare the proposed result without expecting every component to have a separate price. The point is to understand what work and selections the amount represents, and which questions remain open.

A difference in totals can start with a difference in scope.

Hypothetical example, not a Stamp project or estimate: one kitchen proposal replaces cabinets and counters while retaining the existing layout and lighting. Another includes a proposed layout change and new lighting, but leaves the appliance selection open.

Those totals describe different starting points. Before choosing between them, ask each contractor to identify the work included, the work left out and the choices still needed. If you want the same project compared, request clarification against that common scope. If you prefer the smaller project, compare it as a deliberate choice rather than assuming both proposals buy the same result.

An unexplained price difference is a reason to ask a question. It is not evidence, by itself, that one contractor has omitted work or that the other has overcharged.

Compare responsibilities as well as room finishes.

Ask who coordinates the trades, what permit and inspection work the proposal includes, and how questions or changes will be documented. Raise household access concerns, items you intend to retain and any work you are arranging separately. Keep the answers with the relevant proposal revision.

For Stamp's building and remodeling projects, Lindy Stamp is the contractor and project supervisor, working with hand-picked trade partners. Electrical work is usually handled by the company's employee electricians. Ask about the scope of your project rather than assuming every trade is an employee or every possible task is included.

Finish with a short clarification request.

Send the proposal date or revision, the part you are asking about and the answer you need. For example: Does the lighting work include restoring the affected ceiling finish? Which appliance selections are still open? Is the adjoining room included? Clear questions are easier to resolve than a request to make two totals match.

Scope comparison is one part of choosing a project. Before signing, read the complete proposed agreement and the Maryland Home Improvement Commission's current contract guidance. That guidance addresses subjects beyond this comparison, including dates, payment terms and required notices; use qualified legal advice for questions about your agreement.

Maryland MHIC: complete home improvement contract guidance

Bring the scope question to the conversation.

Share the project location, the remodel you are considering and the questions you want to resolve. If you already have a Stamp proposal, identify its date or revision so the conversation uses the right document.

Discuss the project with Stamp
Call Ask

Ask a question